Gendered practices and norms are negotiated and constructed in the communities to which women belong. They are not monolithic or homogeneous. In religion, gendered norms and practices are linked with other domains of social power and with broader theological and philosophical frameworks. At the same time, “… [g]endered norms and practices are imbricated in multiple social domains, working to structure political and religious authority, conceptions of the divine and individual and collective identities… [and] are essential to exploring the complexities of Muslim social worlds, not just the particular experiences of women…” [1].
The tension in dealing with gender in Islam is that Orthodox Islam, largely the determinative public face of Islam, is predominantly androcentric. Male interpreters of the Qur’an and Ahadith highlight the apparent limitations on women in the texts, regulating women’s lives according to patriarchal interpretations and their definitions of the ‘true’ religion. Women must bear the burden as symbols of tradition and modernity, often finding themselves the target of ideological values that shape social values (Hafez, 2011. p 51). Male authority and superiority are upheld by traditional cultural norms. If Islam is understood from what is seen in this public space alone, the reality and nuances of women’s experiences of Islam are hidden and ignored, limiting the understanding of Islam with its many complexities.
But traditional understandings of gender in Islam are changing. There are diverse movements led and embraced by women that contribute to the formation of women’s public theology within Islam. The women’s piety movement has opened traditional spaces to women, allowing them to teach the religious texts with authority and leading to the re-interpretation and application of those texts by women to women’s lives. A new movement of women seeking to interpret the Qur’an and Ahadith through a more egalitarian lens is offering fresh perspectives and understandings that help release women from some of the traditional burdens that have encumbered them. Islamic feminism, for some an oxymoron, is bringing the language of human rights, along with fresh interpretations of the texts, into conversations about the place and role of women in Islam. Women’s activism is another challenge to traditional views of women. Muslim women activists challenge laws and the regulation of women’s behaviour, highlighting injustices and calling for change on behalf of all women. Muslim women in academia are also driving a re-imagination of gender in Islam, challenging both the androcentrism of orthodoxy, the legacy of colonialism and the sensationalised, media-fuelled judgments of the non-Muslim world.
How are we to engage with the diversity that is found in the application of interpretative traditions, reimagination of the nature of God and how he would relate to women, and the changes occurring within Islam from underneath, from women who are laying claim to their desire to be true Muslims who can find equality and identity in the texts that are the core of their faith? What is the invitation of this new generation of Muslim sisters to us who are Christian? In what ways can we together read the stories of God’s encounters with women, and address the myriad of issues women across religious divides are encountering?
[1] Howe, Justine (ed), the Routledge Handbook of Islam and Gender, Routledge, London and New York, 2021. P 21
© When Women Speak … June 2026
CH spent nearly four decades in South Asia and the Middle East working in education, community development and the Church. A co-founder of the When Women Speak… network, her research has included women’s activism and social change in South Asia, violence against women and missiology. She is currently focussed on developing new streams of ministry among women who live under Islam, particularly in the journey to maturity in faith, and enabling women academics and practitioners to shape missiology and mission practice. She holds a PhD in Gender Studies (Australian National University).


Leave a Reply