How do I see?

How do I see?

It is easy for us as outsiders to the context of women’s situations to speak for Muslim women on what their situation is really like. We see incidents and listen to women describe so many of the things that are opposed to our idea of freedom and well-being. Whether it is political discussions in the West about the veil, with the French President for example describing it as ‘a sign of women’s debasement’; the focus on the abuses of women such as we have seen in Iran where the religious police have been responsible for the abuses of young women for violating the country’s hijab laws; or Jordan or Pakistan with their terrible record on honour killings; or Afghanistan where secondary education and work for women has now been deemed illegal for women; the stories are endless, painful, and hard to reconcile.

At the same time, I spent some time a while ago with a friend from my days in Pakistan. She had moved to the UK for study and then married someone from the UK. We caught up after a long time and I was surprised, perhaps even a bit shocked, to find my friend had adopted very conservative forms of Islamic dress and behaviour. As we shared our stories through the years since we had seen each other, I listened to someone describe a hunger for living a good life, one that honoured Allah, and she pursued the practices of her faith for that reason.

A colleague did her PhD on women’s involvement in the mosques in Syria, before the war that has decimated that country. She wrote of women wanting to pursue true faith.

How do we think about the women we are involved in and reach out to them?

  • Role and responsibilities

‘As women … taught to be the guardians of tradition and national identity. As housewives … expected to carry out their domestic chores in their homes. … mothers of future generations and to raise their children as disciplined and obedient citizens’

Women are the ‘entrusted keepers of the family, … often acts as the mediator between the secularizing and modernising projects of the state and the family’

Women living under Islam carry a great burden of responsibility not only for themselves but also for their families. Successful children, a successful husband, a well-run home – it all falls on women.

  • Religiously ideal woman

Criteria for conceptualising a religiously ideal Muslim woman:

  1. the nature of the female (and by implication male) sexuality;
  2. role and function of women in broader society/public sphere, especially the purpose and function of seclusion and veiling for women; and
  3. spousal rights and obligations, especially the role of the wife in marriage

One Muslim scholar wrote this about women: ‘The category of the female gender is constructed primarily in sexual terms. Women are identified with the “irreligious” realm of sexual passion, as repositories of all “lower” aspects of human nature, the very anti-study of “illuminated” sphere of male (religious) knowledge, which is the source of religious authority.’

What this means is that women are a threat to a healthy social order because they can fatally wound men with their sexual attraction.

Yet, I find myself wondering what that means for the many women who pursue the desire to become a true Muslim. They desire a shift from the ignorant traditions of religious customs to a life shaped by informed religious practice.

  • Collective relationships

According to Suad Joseph, collective relationships are based on love and nurture and, paradoxically, power and violence. While connectivity is an expression of love, it is also intimately and intrinsically linked to the reproduction of power within those relationships. One never is just a single person. One always is already a set of relationships, multiple intersections of connectivity. It is the relationships that position a person for access, rights, privileges, resources. It is the relationships that shape selfhood and identity.

Connectivity is about seeing self as part of the other. It joins lives in ways that make separation destructive because it blends autonomy and control. Connectivity can be thought of as the “…psychodymanic processes by which one person comes to see himself or herself as part of another. Boundaries between persons are relatively fluid so that each needs the other to complete the sense of selfhood. One’s sense of self is intimately linked with the self of another so that the security, identity, integrity, dignity, and self-worth of one is tied to the actions of the other… They are open to and require the involvement of others in shaping their emotions, desires, attitudes, and identities ….

  • What this results in is certain expectations about God.

God is expected to protect and provide in response to the honourable submission of his followers. Many of our Muslim sisters find it incongruous to conceive of God excluding them as deficient, as suggested by some interpretations in Islam.

Within Islam today there is a growing body of women who call for a different interpretation of Islam. While we might ignore them as not orthodox, I think to do so ignores that God is working in many different ways. Many of these women are inviting others, including Christians into discussion about the nature of God, what it means to be a woman and a woman of faith.  We need to listen to the different stories and discussions where women’s voices are searching in very different ways for the knowledge and reality of who God is.

Image: pexels-thirdman-8488997.jpg

© When Women Speak … January 2025

CH spent nearly four decades in South Asia and the Middle East working in education, community development and the Church, and has returned as part of Interserve’s International Leadership. A co-founder of the When Women Speak… network, her research has included women’s activism and social change in South Asia, violence against women and missiology. She is currently focussed on developing new streams of ministry among women who live under Islam and enabling women academics and practitioners to shape missiology and mission practice. She holds a PhD in Gender Studies (Australian National University).

1707 2560 When Women Speak

Leave a Reply

Start Typing